With Maryland among 18 states taking up medical assisted suicide in their respective legislatures in 2024, it looks to neighboring Washington D.C. as an example.
As the nation grapples with evolving perspectives on Medical assisted suicide as some of the available end-of-life options, the right-to-die movement continues to gain momentum, with a flurry of recent legislative activity, especially across the eastern half of the United States.
D.C.’s Medical Assisted Suicide Death with Dignity Act has years of data to offer
In Washington, D.C., the implementation of the Death with Dignity Act over the past several years has provided insights into the impact of physician-assisted death for folks diagnosed with a terminal illness. As Sapna Bansil wrote for the Baltimore Post-Examiner, legislators in neighboring Maryland will soon contemplate a bill of their own – the End of Life Option Act (HB403).
We can examine the experiences of those who chose medical assisted suicide in the nation’s capitol to help shed light on the complex nuances surrounding this personal choice. Between 2017 and 2022, 24 terminally ill patients in Washington, D.C. exercised their right to choose when and how they died. As part of the requirements mandated by the legislation, D.C. officials must release annual reports detailing these cases.
Right-to-die supporters include healthcare professionals
Dixcy Bosley, a D.C. nurse care manager specializing in hospice and end-of-life care, said she has been with five patients at the moment when they ingested the life-ending medication that doctors prescribed.
All five, Bosley said, had “really peaceful experience[s].” Moreover, she noted, the patients she knew who chose aid in dying didn’t necessarily want to stop living – they “really just wanted to stop suffering,” she said.
Most hopeful for Medical assistance in Death are the patients who might benefit
Baltimore native Diane Kraus, a 59-year-old woman who was diagnosed in May 2021 with metastatic breast cancer, says it’s become increasingly difficult for her to manage her symptoms through a series of ongoing chemotherapy treatments.
Kraus, who spent 35 years working as an occupational therapist in hospice and home health settings before falling ill, says her support for legalizing Death with Dignity in USA has always been a personal decision. After having watched many of her patients come to their end of life , they would plead to “go home painlessly or get some form of medical assisted painless death and… be with their relatives,” she said. Now that she’s unfortunately faced with a similar circumstance, Kraus said she, too, wants to have that choice to die peacefully when the time comes.
Maryland Governor is willing to approve a bill for Medical assisted death into law
Somewhat a strange statement , Governor Wes Moore has publicly announced his explicit support for bringing expanded voluntary end-of-life options to Maryland ahead of potential legislation, saying “If a bill makes it to my desk… I will sign it.”
Ultimately, no matter what the available data from Washington D.C. and the ten states where medical aid in dying is permitted shows, it will be up to legislators in Maryland (and in the other 17 states that will hear assisted-death bills in 2024) to listen to the will of their constituents and pass the End of Life Option Act.
For more information on how to get involved in efforts to bring a Death with Dignity law to Maryland, please visit the state page on our website.
Read the full article below:
As Maryland considers medical aid in dying, here’s how it’s playing out in DC
By: Sapna Bansil
Published: January 27, 2024
WASHINGTON – A 74-year-old man with Lou Gehrig’s disease. An 88-year-old man with congestive heart failure. A 54-year-old woman with cancer.
These are among the 24 terminally ill patients who, between 2017 and 2022, ended their lives under Washington, D.C.’s Death with Dignity Act, according to public records. The law gives D.C. residents with incurable illnesses the option to die by ingesting lethal medication and requires the government to generate annual reports on those who choose to do so.
Those reports are of interest this year as legislatures across the country push to expand access to medical aid-in-dying options like the one in D.C. In neighboring Maryland and Virginia, for example, measures to legalize the procedure are now pending in the legislatures.
In Maryland, aid-in-dying proposals in past years have faced pushback from a number of opponents. Religious groups and pro-life activists argue it infringes on their belief in the sanctity of life. Physicians fear it may violate medical ethics. Disability rights groups worry that aid in dying would be used to encourage individuals with disabilities to end their lives.
But advocates say there’s unprecedented momentum this year for an aid-in-dying law in Maryland – in part because arguments for the option have been strengthened by its implementation in D.C. and 10 other states.
People in Maryland “should feel safe knowing that it’s tried and tested,” said Donna Smith, the Maryland and D.C. campaign director for the nonprofit group Compassion and Choices. “It’s not a large number of people that use this, but for the people that need it, it’s everything.”
In 2016, D.C. became the sixth jurisdiction in the nation to pass aid-in-dying legislation. According to a Capital News Service analysis of annual reports released by the D.C. Department of Health, the 24 people who have died under the law ranged in age from 40 to 98. Seventeen patients had cancer, while others had neurological, heart, or lung conditions.
Data was available through February 2022. The District officially counts 23 people as having utilized aid in dying; however, 24 patients are listed in Department of Health records.
Many who sought aid in dying did so to end their suffering, according to Dixcy Bosley, a nurse care manager in D.C. who specializes in hospice and end-of-life care. As a volunteer with Compassion and Choices, Bosley has counseled several patients in the District who pursued it as an option.
“I’ve been with five people,” Bosley said, “and every single one was just a really peaceful experience.”
Bosley recalled the first aid-in-dying patient she cared for in the District: A man in his 60s and former electrician who depended on an oxygen tank to breathe. To be eligible, patients must have less than six months to live, make a series of oral and written requests, and be sound of mind.
Bosley said she was struck by how the man planned for his death. He set a date and had family and friends visit to say their goodbyes.
“He was not suicidal,” Bosley said. “He really just wanted to stop suffering.”
On the day he died, his wife and daughter were by his side as he mixed and ingested the medication. Through the cracked windows in his room, they could hear the sounds of a neighboring elementary school.
“We could hear the kids in the elementary school playing and laughing outside,” Bosley said. “I just felt like it was just a beautiful death.”
Concerns about ethics and access
Fewer people have utilized aid in dying in D.C. than advocates had expected, according to Smith.
Among the biggest barriers to accessing the procedure is the lack of doctors and pharmacies willing to provide care. In D.C., there have never been more than four physicians who have prescribed life-ending medications in any given year, the CNS analysis found.
And according to Bosley, many retail pharmacies refuse to fill aid-in-dying prescriptions. (Major retailers declined or did not respond to CNS requests to discuss their policies on this.)
The Medical Society of the District of Columbia, which represents physicians in the District, did not offer an opinion as the D.C. Council was debating its law in 2015 and 2016. A spokesperson for the group declined to comment for this story.
However many providers said that aid in dying is inconsistent with their obligations to treat and heal their patients.
“People bristle at the idea that we would be able to heal through killing,” said Daniel Sulmasy, a physician who serves as director of the Kennedy Institute of Ethics at Georgetown University, located in D.C. “This is something that I think grates against the fundamentals of the profession.”
MedStar Georgetown University Hospital prohibits doctors from participating in the District’s aid-in-dying program, according to Sulmasy.
“We can stop treatments and make sure people are comfortable, but we never act with the specific intention of making somebody dead,” he said.
Within the advocate community, there are also concerns about racial disparities in accessing medical assisted suicide .
In D.C., where 45% of the population is Black, 22 of 24 patients who have utilized the option are white, the CNS analysis found. One patient was Black, while another was Hispanic.
Similar trends have appeared in other states that have legalized aid in dying. In California, among the most racially diverse jurisdictions with an aid-in-dying law, 0.8% of patients have been Black.
The disparities stem, in part, from broader health inequities, Smith surmises.
“I know in [the Black] community, we’re still fighting to live,” said Smith, who serves as the diversity, equity, and inclusion advisor to Compassion and Choices. “We don’t get adequate health outcomes to begin with. So it’s hard to say, ‘Okay, let me offer you this option [at the end of life]’ when you haven’t been given the support you need to live.”
Prospects in Maryland
Maryland is among 18 states currently weighing aid-in-dying legislation. The bill is modeled after existing laws across the country and is the same as a measure that failed to make it out of committee a year ago.
Like in other jurisdictions, the bill would require patients to self-ingest medication. Physicians and health-care facilities are not obligated to provide aid-in-dying services.
Similar measures have been considered in Maryland in the past but failed to pass – though they came close. In 2019, the House of Delegates approved an aid-in-dying bill that failed in the Senate on a 23-23 tie vote.
This year, as issues of bodily autonomy gain heightened awareness following the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, Maryland Senate President Bill Ferguson, D-Baltimore City, has indicated a willingness to bring an aid-in-dying bill to a vote.
Governor Wes Moore has also expressed support for bringing the option to Maryland.
“If a bill makes it to my desk with transition with dignity at its core, I will sign it,” Moore said.
Senate Minority Leader Stephen Hershey, R-Kent, Queen Anne’s, Caroline, and Cecil expect most Republicans to oppose such a bill.
“From a perspective of the sanctity of life, a lot of times, it boils down to our religious beliefs on some issues,” Hershey said. “This is certainly one of them.”
Among those who hope the Maryland bill passes is Diane Kraus, a 59-year-old Baltimore native who was diagnosed in May 2021 with metastatic breast cancer and has since been advocating for the right to medical assisted suicide and end her life.
Kraus has undergone four different types of chemotherapy and continues to receive treatment every three weeks. But it’s become increasingly difficult for her to manage her symptoms, which include pain, nausea, confusion, and headaches, among others.
Motivated by her own experiences with a terminal illness and 35 years of working as an occupational therapist in hospice and home health settings, Kraus testified in support of Maryland’s aid-in-dying bill last year.
“I wanted it for me,” Kraus said in an interview with CNS. “I had seen so many people die in pain and so many people have such a poor quality of life at the very end. And they would say, ‘I just want to go home and be with God and be with my relatives.’ … And that just really struck me.”
Kraus was devastated when Maryland’s bill stalled last year and has considered relocating to a state where aid in dying is legal. She hopes that existing laws, like the one in D.C., help sway skeptics in Maryland this legislative term.
“Even people highly opposed…come around to some degree when they see it and have to live with it,” Kraus said.